Sheet N3 · Numerical validation

Air-inlet valve at a high point (Wylie & Streeter, example 5-2)

Source : E. B. Wylie, V. L. Streeter, Fluid Transients, McGraw-Hill, 1978, example 5-2, program D-1 and results D-2

1. The question

When the pressure drops at the high point, an air valve lets air in and then expels it. Does CBELIER reproduce the head at the valve and the air volume and mass computed by the book?

2. The case

varying inflow610 m, D 0.61 m610 m, D 0.61 mdownstream reservoirN1N2: air valve

Two 610 m pipes connect a varying inflow, 16·(0.75 − 0.25·sin 0.3t) ft³/s, to a downstream reservoir, through an air valve at the high point (elevation 10.36 m). The book computes with one reach per pipe and a 0.5 s step; so does CBELIER.

3. Data and status

DataValueStatus
Pipes: L, D, wave speed2 × 610 m; 0.61 m; 1,219 m/sPUBLISHED
Friction factor; initial flow0.02; 0.34 m³/sPUBLISHED
Air valve: elevation; inlet Cd; outlet Cd; opening10.36 m; 0.65; 0.975; 0.02 ft²PUBLISHED
Downstream reservoir9.75 mPUBLISHED
Time step; reaches per pipe0.5 s; 1PUBLISHED

4. Results

0510152025024681012time (s)head (m)CBELIER, N2book, N2CBELIER, N1book, N1
Heads at the air valve (N2) and upstream (N1): CBELIER (lines) and book (circles).

5. Differences

IndicatorCBELIERReferenceDifference
Maximum head difference, air valve N20.13 m——
Maximum head difference, upstream N1 (at peaks)0.58 m—tolerance 0.6 m
Maximum air volume (20.28 ft³)0.578 m³0.574 m³0.7 %
Air mass at 12 s (0.0388 slug)0.574 kg0.566 kg1.4 %

The head at the air valve follows the book within 0.15 m, the upstream head within 0.6 m at the oscillation peaks; the maximum air volume and the air mass are reproduced within 2 %. The air-valve law (four-regime compressible orifice) is therefore consistent.

6. Limitations and assumptions